HollywoodJesus.com: Pop Culture From A Spiritual Point of View
MoviesDVDsMusicBooksComixTVGamesSportsThe Hit ListWeekly Sweeps at HJHWJ Blogs
Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Subscribe | About

HJ Live!  Search HJ Live! Advanced SearchLogin
Share This!

Click Icon >>

Christmas Movie Eliminator
The Galactic Gazette: Star Wars News at HJ
Focus on the Force: Star Wars Commentary and Analysis at HJ
The Pipeline: What's In Store for Faith and Film
Film Festival Roundup
HJ's iON Comic-Con
Bagshot Row Bulletin: News of the film, commentary about the book
The Hobbit
Hobbits of Color Need Not Apply
Bagshot Row Bulletin

According to a report in today’s New York Times Arts Beat Blog, a casting agent for the upcoming Hobbit films recently posted an advertisement looking for extras with “light skin tones.”

According to the Agence France-Presse, an actor with a Pakistani background was dismissed at a casting session, and promptly started a Facebook group, “Hire hobbits of all colours! Say no to hobbit racism!”

A spokesperson for Peter Jackson’s Wingnut Films has stated that the casting director had received no such instructions, and the studio does not condone discrimination. According to a report on CNN’s Entertainment Blog, the casting director in question has been dismissed.

JRR Tolkien’s Prologue to The Lord of the Rings contains a section titled “Concerning Hobbits,” which tells us that the Harfoots (apparently ancestors of the Bagginses and other Hobbits of the Shire) “were browner of skin” than other Hobbits. It would seem that most Hobbits in the Third Age might be considered “people of color.”

Tolkien has sometimes been accused of racial prejudice. The passage in “Concerning Hobbits” seems to discredit that view. Let’s hope that Jackson and crew will continue to dismiss those who seem uninformed about Tolkien’s intentions, instead of dismissing actors based on their skin tone.


Leave a Reply

Subscribe without commenting


Click Icon >>

The Hobbit... Whole: Movie and Book
Bagshot Row Bulletin: News of the film, commentary about the book
Hobbit Commentary
The Galactic Gazette: Star Wars News at HJ
Focus on the Force: Star Wars Commentary and Analysis at HJ
Narnia News, with Mark Sommer
Narnia Features
Hogwarts Expressions
The Lord of the Rings, with Greg Wright
The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe

Click Icon >>

From the Top
eMPULSE: What's Hot In Electronic Media
Video Reviews
charActor studies
Sound Off
WWTD: What Would Tebow Do?
The Guide: Video Reviews of Hot Games at HJ
Church at Louie's
KJV@400: Not Just Any Old Book
Pokemon White: Catch 'Em All
Madden NFL Playoff Sims
The LOST Lockup: Archives
The Lost Library
Get Cupped Up: World Cup Coverage at HJ
Fan of the Flame
12 Days of Christmas Music
EA Sports Active 30-Day Challenge
Wolverine Spotlight
Galacticana: Melinda Ledman on Battlestar
SteinWatch: News of Ben Stein and Expelled
Tales From The Front Lines: From the set of The Bill Collector
Yo's Animal Crossing Diary
Favre Watch at HJ
The Back Page: The Intersection of Culture and Spirituality
After Eden: Sifting the Gold From the Gutter
Mii Fit: Yo's 30-Day Fitness Challenge
The Blogger Archives
Danger: The Real Missionary Position
The Dark Corner: Philip Pullman at HJ

Click Icon >>

Reflections for Moviegoers, with Matt Kinne
The Virtual Pew, with Mike Furches
Hollywood Jesus Books